1. Health
You can opt-out at any time. Please refer to our privacy policy for contact information.
Vincent Iannelli, M.D.

When is an Accident a Crime? When Should Parents be Charged?

By July 23, 2011

Follow me on:

The Web-based Injury Statistics Query and Reporting System (WISQARS) from the CDC lists unintentional injuries (accidents) as the leading cause of death for children in most age groups.

The only exception is for younger children under 12 months old, for whom accidents are the 5th leading cause of death. At this age, congenital anomalies, premature birth, SIDS, and maternal pregnancy complications rank higher than accidents as a cause of death. Still, 1,285 infants under the age of 12 months died because of accidents in 2007.

But when is an unintentional injury, such as a car accident, drowning, fall, or shooting accident a crime and not just an accident?

When these incidents are reported, they are usually described as tragic accidents. It is not that often that you hear about a parent being charged with a crime. It does happen though.

One recent incident involves Raquel Nelson of Marietta, Georgia who could be sentenced to up to three years in prison for homicide by vehicle in the second degree after her 4-year-old son was hit and killed while she crossed in middle of a busy street at night with her three children. They had just gotten off a city bus and were crossing with other people, as the nearest crosswalk was at the end of the block. The driver of the car was charged with hit and run, first-degree vehicular homicide, and cruelty to children and has already been sentenced to six months in jail.

Will Raquel Nelson go to jail? Could she serve more jail time than the man who was driving the car that hit her son and then left the scene of the accident? While that is the concern of many bloggers and the petitions to overturn her conviction, it is important to note that second degree homicide by vehicle is a misdemeanor in Georgia and the judge can exercise discretion in sentencing so that she only receives a suspended sentence or probation.

That's what happened in Antioch, California early this month, when Lindsey Ann Isch got four years probation and community service, instead of jail time, after being convicted of vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated, drunken driving causing injury, and child endangerment after she got into an accident that killed her 1-year-old son.

A similar thing happened to Jessica Holmes of Chandler, Oklahoma, who got a suspended sentence after being charged and convicted of second-degree manslaughter after she forgot her roommate's 2-year-old daughter in her car, instead of dropping her off at daycare.

There have been many other charges being filed against mothers associated with kids in hot cars, although these have not gotten as much attention as the Raquel Nelson case. They include:

  • a mother in Brownsville, Texas who is being charged with involuntary manslaughter after her 3-year-old got into an old van outside their house and died after being in the hot car for at least two hours
  • a mother near Palmview, Texas who is being charged with manslaughter after her 18-month-old died after being accidentally left in a hot car for about two hours
  • a mother in North Virginia who has been indicted on charges of felony murder and child neglect after her son, who was almost three-years-old, died in her hot car after she forgot to drop him off at day care
  • two mothers in Louisville, Kentucky, whose infants were fortunately rescued before they were in their hot cars for too long

It isn't just mothers who get charged though. The father and step-grandfather of a 4-year-old boy who drowned in Wyoming last week are being charged with aggravated homicide after their canoe crashed and flipped over. In addition to drinking, the men had been warned about canoeing in the fast running river.

Some of these cases highlight an important difference between an accident and a crime. The two mothers who were shopping intentionally left their children, one who was as young as four-weeks-old, in a hot car with the windows up and the air conditioner turned off. They knew their kids were in the car and should have known that they were at risk from the heat. The men in the canoe were drinking alcohol and ignored a warning.

What about the case in Virginia? In this case too, there does seem to be some extra circumstances that could possibly be relevant. It seems that she had previously left her child in her car outside work in January, but he was discovered about a half hour later when her day care provider called to ask if he would be coming that day.

And the two cases in South Texas? The charges seem to be related to the fact that the mothers lost track of their toddlers for several hours. A similar argument was used by the Deputy District Attorney in Las Vegas where a mother was recently sentenced to 24 to 60 months after her 2-year-old drowned in a backyard pool, saying that "an accident is when a mother loses track of a child for five minutes not five hours."

But it takes much less than five minutes for a child to drown, fall out of a window, or find a locked gun, so why should that be a criteria for whether an accident is caused by neglect?

These cases raise a lot of questions. Why are some parents charged with crimes after accidents, when many others aren't, after the very same accidents? Why do only some types of accidents seem to trigger charges? What is the point of charging parents with a crime after an accident?

Negligence, typically defined as "failure to exercise the care that a reasonably prudent person would exercise in like circumstances," should likely be one of the factors that is used to determine if something is more than a simple accident. Unfortunately, people have different ideas of what negligence is. Many parents think it is negligent to have a pool without a fence around it or to have a loaded gun in the house, while others don't think twice about these hazards.

The bigger discussion though should likely be on how to reduce these accidents and tragedies. Spread the word about securing guns, locking cars so that kids can't get inside and die in the heat, the importance of childproofing the house and pool, using window guards, and having kids wear coast guard approved life jackets when they are near the water and don't know how to swim, etc.

Follow us on Twitter and Facebook
Hot car death a horrible mistake, not murder
Swim Lessons for Kids
Lawn Mower Accidents

July 23, 2011 at 4:49 pm
(1) Echo says:

This is insane. Isn’t this mother punished enough by having lost her child? Now they’re going to punish her other children by taking her away? For JAYWALKING that led to a tragedy? I’m disgusted.

July 23, 2011 at 5:47 pm
(2) Vincent Iannelli, MD says:

“Now they’re going to punish her other children by taking her away? For JAYWALKING that led to a tragedy?”

What about the other cases?

Do those parents deserve to be charged?

Is there ever a situation when a parent should be charged when their actions lead to the death or severe injury to one of their children?

October 8, 2011 at 7:37 am
(3) disgusted says:

Pity they will not charge Parents in Australia. We just had a little toddler killed on a railway line and his little friend injured he was 3 and she was 4. Mum did not even have a fence on the back of the house but all they were interested was checking the poor train driver whose life has been ruined and covering up mum. Said the train driver could not have done anything else after investigation. Never said mum could have looked after the children and had a fence as well Transport Minister said he did not want to go into that and Police on mums side. Another mother left her 6 months old baby girl in the car while she went to work at a school in Toowomba baby died all sympathy for mum and again no charges laid. Children suffer at the hands of paents but Police and othes in authority who never want to blame the parents.

May 1, 2013 at 5:59 pm
(4) Cindy says:

I met a woman here in my town. Her family was on the way home from a trip. She and her two children had fallen to sleep in the car while Dad was driving. Dad fell to sleep and drove off the road. The two children were okay but Mom had to have a metal hip put in. The DA tried to charge the Dad with endangering the children. Can you imagine! That’s crazy. Maybe if he had been drunk I would cut the DA some room here, but for a family trip to have ended with the whole family falling to sleep, that was just wrong.

February 24, 2014 at 9:46 pm
(5) David says:

To Echo, what if in these cases, it was another parent who was in charge of watching the children? Do you feel like the mothers and fathers of the children would just say that it’s alright, they feel bad enough? What if a gun accidentally goes off while being cleaned and it kills a neighbors child out in their lawn? And saying that all that mother did was Jaywalk is ridiculous. She was crossing an obviously busy street with multiple children. If it was a sound and safe decision, her child wouldn’t have died. It’s like saying that it’s not dangerous to take you kids for a swim…neglecting the fact that you’re swimming in a fast flowing river. It’s a GOOD thing that they will be placing those children into the hands of relatives, because they might actually have the sense to not drag the kids out into a busy street. Just as this article is trying to point out, there are differences (albeit slight) between truly accidental cases and negligence ones.

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>
Top Related Searches
  • bado
  • parents
    1. About.com
    2. Health
    3. Pediatrics

    ©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.

    We comply with the HONcode standard
    for trustworthy health
    information: verify here.