To understand the guideline, it is important to first understand what it doesn't say. The guideline specifically do not say that antibiotics can't be used to treat ear infections anymore. Instead, they offer guidelines so that you can choose which children may not need antibiotics to treat their ear infection and may be simply observed instead.
The most clear part of the guidelines is that children under six months of age should always be treated with antibiotics when they have an ear infection. For children between six months and two years of age, they should also be prescribed antibiotics if your Pediatrician is sure of their diagnosis, or if they are unsure, but your child has severe symptoms, like severe ear pain or a fever at or above 102.2 degrees Fahrenheit. Older children, over 2 years of age, usually don't need antibiotics at first, unless they have severe symptoms, and can instead be managed using an 'observation option'.
The Observation OptionIf your child meets the criteria described above and does not have any other medical problems, like Down syndrome, immune system problems, cleft palate, or a cochlear implant, then they may qualify to be observed without being treated with antibiotics. If these children do not improve or worsen over the next 48 to 72 hours, then they should be prescribed antibiotics. This may mean a return visit to your Pediatrician in some cases, but this may also be done over the phone, or by use of a 'safety-net' antibiotic prescription which your doctor gives you to fill just in case.
This method of observation instead of prescribing antibiotics right away has been working successfully in many other countries and has few risks. It works because most kids with ear infections will likely get better on their own anyway. These children aren't simply left in pain though. The guidelines strongly recommend steps be taken to reduce the child's pain using acetaminophen or ibuprofen.
If your child has had an ear infection in the previous 30 days or has chronic fluid in their ears, then they will need antibiotics and won't qualify for the 'observation option'.
Diagnosis of Ear InfectionsFor parents who read the full guidelines, one of the most surprising things is going to be the talk about the 'uncertain diagnosis' of ear infections. It should seem like a clear cut thing. You look inside a child's ear and you can tell if it is infected or not, right?
It isn't always that simple though. Younger children's ears can be difficult to see, especially for health professionals who don't treat a lot of children. The doctor may mistake fluid in the ear for an infection, not even see the ear drum because of ear wax, or they may confuse an ear that is red from fever or crying to be from an infection.
If your doctor has said things like 'it looks a little red' or 'I see a little fluid' then they may not have been making a 'certain' diagnosis of an ear infection. This is especially true if the diagnosis was made when your child had no other symptoms at all. With a true ear infection, in addition to having fluid in their ear, your child should instead have the more classic symptoms of 'a history of rapid onset of signs and symptoms such as otalgia (or pulling of the ear in an infant), irritability in an infant or toddler, otorrhea, and/or fever.'